| Platinum | Anthony's Restaurant & Lounge |
| Gold | Bella Napeoli |
| Silver | Cascone's Italian Restaurant |
| Bronze | Garozzo's Ristorante |
| Top Pick | Italian Delight |
| Top Pick | Jasper's |
| Top Pick | Le Fou Frog |
| Top Pick | Nick and Ana's |
| Top Pick | Nick and Nino's Pub |
| Top Pick | The North End |